[Pw_forum] Negative frequencies in phonon calculation

Alberto Milani alberto.milani at chem.polimi.it
Thu Oct 6 13:35:43 CEST 2005


Dear Jose,
Thank for your help.
I know well the problems about saddle points and negative frequencies because 
I usually calculate normal modes of molecules where this problem occurs many 
times.
Here the problem is that I am studying an infinite linear chain and so I found 
strange that some kind of saddle point could be the source of the problem for 
such a system. Many other ab-initio calculation on polyyne finite chain have 
shown that these systems are indeed stable as linear chains (no negative 
frequencies are found). So I would exclude any kind of transversal 
deformartion from linearity.
From this point of view, there is no possibility for any saddle point and the 
relaxed structure that I have obtained should be considered converged in a 
well defined minimum. In fact, no negative frequencies are found for the 
longitudinal phonons.
So I think that the problem here is not the usual saddle instability. I wonder 
if the code fails in some other way in stabilizing the linear chain (e.g. 
choice of the functional, pseudopotential, ...).
Thank you again for your attention.
Yours,
A. M.



More information about the Pw_forum mailing list